Best Dessert St. Augustine: Our Top 10 Picks

Dessert in St. Augustine is a must. Whether you love chocolate, ice cream, cupcakes, or fudge, you'll find something to satisfy your sweet tooth in St. Augustine. After you've whipped up a meal in your full condo kitchen or Creston House, or dined at one of the best St. Augustine restaurants, treat yourself to a delicious sweet treat at our favorite spots for dessert in St. Augustine.

Best Dessert St. Augustine

Crème de la Cocoa

Creme de la Cocoa has cakes, chocolates, cookies, ice cream, and more. Their desserts are decadent and delicious. They offer everything from custom wedding cakes to grab and go baked goods. Get something for the evening or stock up for your whole stay!

You can also find their desserts at Odd Birds Café in Vilano.

Address: 299 San Marco Ave.

The Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops

Cool down with a delicious Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pop. Hyppo's handmade ice pops are made with fresh fruits, herbs, and cane sugar and come in more than 450 different flavors. You can even find The Hyppo ice cream trucks around town, which also serves Mayday Ice Cream.

Address: 48 Charlotte St.

Mayday Ice Cream

With locations in St. Augustine, Jacksonville, and Lakeland, Mayday Ice Cream offers artisan quality ice cream in innovative and delicious flavors. Get Mayday Ice Cream on the go from one of the Hyppo and Mayday trucks throughout the region.

Address: 1835 US-1 #127, In Seabridge Square

ChocoLattes

ChocoLattes is known for their beautiful and creative cakes, but you can stop by and get delicious bakery goods from here as well. Try their frozen rose, cake pops, or mini cheesecakes!

Address: 47 Cordova St.

Sweet City Cupcakes 

Sweet City Cupcakes has just about any kind of cake you could want: wedding cakes, custom cakes, cupcakes, and even cookie cakes. You can get full size and mini versions of their "edible art." 

Address: 233 W King St Suite A

Marble Slab Creamery

Marble Slab serves up 38 flavors of homemade ice cream and dozens of mix-in options to customize your unique creation. They are known for their famous cold marble slab. In addition to ice cream, you can get cookies, pies, brownies, and more. 

Address: 1053 A1A Beach Blvd, In Anastasia Plaza 

Luli’s Cupcakes 

Luli's was the first cupcake shop in St. Augustine, and it's been a local favorite since it opened in 2008. You can get just about any kind of flavor cupcake here, as well as vegan and gluten-free options. 

Address: 82 San Marco Ave

Savannah Sweets

Get sweet treats for everyone in the family at Savannah Sweets. Find caramel apples, pralines, fudge, chocolate covered candies, and so much more here!

Address: 81 St. George St., #A 

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard offers a wide selection of flavors and combinations. Get Italian ice, cream ice, frozen custard, cookie sandwiches, milkshakes, and more. Call ahead for the flavors of the day! 

Address: 380 A1A Beach Blvd 

Les Petits Pleasures

Les Petits Pleasures is a French bakery and patisserie offering a wide selection of beautifully crafted treats. Check out the regularly rotating menu of fresh baked goods and lunch options here. 

Address: 125 A1A Beach Blvd

Cousteau’s Waffle and Milkshake Bar

Get handmade Belgian Liege waffles and hand-spun milkshakes at Cousteau's. Everything here is made in-house with fresh ingredients, like homemade ice cream toppings, fresh whipped cream, and housemade waffle dough cooked to perfection for each order. 

Address: 15 Hypolita St.